In a recent conversation with one of my colleagues at my day job, we discussed the transformation of the music industry from the beginning of the digital age with compact discs to the current download-a-minute age. The latter provides a fix for those music aficionados who simply must have their favorite band’s new release right now without the inconvenience of leaving their couch. It’s this kind of instant gratification that is personified in fantasy baseball owner’s quickness to dismiss the highly regarded prospects that don’t produce gaudy numbers at the same speedy rate they download the latest Vampire Weekend album.
For those who haven’t falling into the pool of anxiety stricken, impatient owners I offer you the post-hype prospects. The luster may have worn off to a certain degree, but the future is just as bright for many of these guys. The following players have appeared on one of Baseball America’s Top 100 Prospects lists over the last three years and at least some of them have seemingly been discarded by fantasy owners.
THE POST-HYPE PROSPECTS (in no particular order)
- Dioner Navarro, C, Rays
- Ian Stewart, 3b, Rockies
- Brandon Wood, 3b, Angels
- Matt Garza, SP, Rays
- Alex Gordon, 3b, Royals
- Jeremy Hermida, OF, Marlins
- Carlos Quentin, OF, White Sox
- Scott Olsen, SP, Marlins
- Lastings Milledge, OF, Nationals
- Jeff Mathis, C, Angels
- Brandon League, RP, Blue Jays
- Josh Barfield, 2b, Indians
- Fred Lewis, OF, Giants
- Neil Walker, 3b, Pirates
- Edwin Jackson, SP, Rays
There are probably other players I’ve omitted, but either way you get the point. A couple players on this list have started to warm up the hype machine again, namely Jeremy Hermida, Alex Gordon, Brandon Wood, and Carlos Quentin. These guys have all had ridiculous potential at some point in their career and while some owners have already lost patience with him, they don’t figure to come at a bargain price on draft day.
A couple guys on the list who I’m particularly intrigued by are Navarro and Barfield.
In the case of Navarro, he was the Yankees catcher of the future just four years ago and he’s still just 24. A couple reasons for optimism include his solid contact rate and increasing fly ball rate, which portends of a breakout in the power department. The other reason for enthusiasm is his promising September line (.310 with three homers, 16 runs, and 10 RBI) . With little other than Shawn Riggans challenging him for at bats this season, he should have an opportunity to build upon that late season success.
Then there is Barfield, who was a highly regarded prospect before hitting .162 in April and eventually being passed up by Asdrubal Cabrera for the starting second base job in Cleveland. Cabrera is a solid player in his own right and might hold onto the job, but Barfield is too talented to not catch on elsewhere. His contact rate was climbing steadily before it dipped last season but it’s important to note that his speed skills and fly ball rate are still both on the rise and with a little more luck and opportunity, the breakout that has alluded him could become a reality.
Sure it takes plenty of faith to invest in some of these failed talents, but it’s just too premature to write them off entirely and while your competition is drafting this year’s hot prospect 10 rounds too early, you can sit on guys like Navarro and scoop them up in your drafts final rounds. The return on that investment may not be quite as significant, but neither will the cost.